Beliefs Faithful Viewer News

Reza Aslan tries to make a ‘Believer’ out of everyone

Reza Aslan in India, for the CNN show “Believer.” Photo courtesy of CNN

(RNS) Maybe it was the moment the nearly naked, ash-smeared guru asked Reza Aslan, the religion scholar and best-selling author, to eat a piece of human brain.

Or maybe it was when the same guru, camped on the banks of the Ganges River at the crematory city of Varanasi, India, smeared human ashes on Aslan’s face and hair.

Or maybe it was when the guru, taking a break from drinking alcohol from a hollowed out human skull, began dancing around the fire, drinking his own urine.

Whatever it was, Aslan, the host of CNN’s new six-part series “Believer,” knew he wanted to get the bleep outta there.

“I was there to get to know and learn from him and to him it was, ‘You are now mine,'” Aslan said in between television appearances to promote the show, which premieres Sunday (March 5). “It was, ‘You belong to me,’ and I just thought, ‘Oh no, I am in way over my head.'”

Reza Aslan bathes in the Ganges River in India for the CNN show “Believer.” Photo courtesy of CNN

But Aslan escaped with his head intact — despite the guru’s ultimate threat to cut it off. What changed was Aslan’s perspective on the Aghoris, a Hindu sect that believes, contrary to the Hindu caste system, that no one is pollutable or impure because God dwells in all.

And that is the point of “Believer”: to use Aslan’s hip-deep immersion in some obscure corner of the faith world to show that people of different religious persuasions — even the ones generally considered marginal, dangerous or just plain “out there” — have more in common than they know.

“My focus has often been on the lived experience of religion, yes,” Aslan said. “So I did not want to do a show where I traveled around the world and pointed to a community and said, ‘My, don’t they look interesting.’ I wanted to focus on the things that people believe, why they believe them and show what those beliefs have in common with what, you, the viewer, believe.”

So after Aslan flees the guru — the most extreme example of Aghorism — he winds up at an Aghori orphanage and school, where children, regardless of their caste, are treated as equals in the eyes of God, and an Aghori nursing home where those with leprosy — considered the most polluted persons by many in India — are treated with compassion and dignity.

“Everybody talks about putting their faith into practice, that religion is not just supposed to be the things that you believe or the things that you do,” Aslan said as an elderly woman’s leprotic foot is bathed and dressed by an Aghori volunteer. “You want to know what putting your faith into practice looks like? This is what it looks like.”

And that’s the general template of all the episodes provided for preview. In each one, Aslan encounters a faith group that appears completely whacky. But instead of recoiling in shock or disgust, he digs deeper, asks more questions, stays longer until finally, he uncovers what he describes as some underlying, universal truth.

Reza Aslan with JeZus on the CNN show “Believer.” Photo courtesy of CNN

In an episode about a doomsday group in Hawaii, Aslan watches as the leader, a wild-haired man who goes by the name of “JeZus,” prances and wails and declares himself God. But when he talks to JeZus and his followers about what they believe, he uncovers an environmentalism that would be recognized by many Christians as “creation care.”

And when he travels to Haiti to investigate the tug of war between the island’s native practitioners of voodoo (known in Haiti as “Vodou”) and evangelical Christian missionaries, he finds himself in the middle of thousands of Haitians chanting “Fall down, devil” as people possessed by “lwa” — spirits — writhe and jerk among them. But a trip to a voodoo temple reveals the faith is focused on one God who has intermediaries — just like Catholic saints.

Other episodes take Aslan to explore ultra-Orthodox Judaism in Israel, Santa Muerte in Mexico and Scientology in the U.S. For each segment, he and his crew spent seven to 10 days with each group.

Reza Aslan participates in a Vodou ceremony in the CNN show “Believer.” Photo courtesy of CNN

The series reflects the fact that Aslan is himself a bit of a spiritual tourist. Of Iranian descent, he converted to Christianity as a teenager, then converted back to Islam before graduate school. He attended a Catholic university and then went on to Harvard Divinity School. His books have ranged from an argument for liberal interpretation of Islam (“No god but God“) to the nature of religious violence (“Beyond Fundamentalism“) to a biography of Jesus (“Zealot“). His wife, the entrepreneur Jessica Jackley, is a Christian.

“There were a lot of new experiences I absorbed intellectually,” he said of filming the series. “But the things I took away from it were all emotional, all spiritual. I think about the spirituality I experienced in the Aghori leprosy community … and at the Santa Muerte Mass on Dia de los Muertos, where I was standing shoulder to shoulder with people I would cross the street to avoid, and yet I had a deep spiritual connection with them. It is those feelings that have stayed with me and really only strengthened my faith.”

Faithful Viewer logo. Religion News Service graphic by T.J. Thomson

About the author

Kimberly Winston

Kimberly Winston is a freelance religion reporter based in the San Francisco Bay Area.


Click here to post a comment

  • Now that the media has normalized Trump, they are moving on to normalize weirdo extremist fringe cults? Great.

    Reza Aslan says: “I wanted to focus on the things that people believe … and show what those beliefs have in common with what, you, the viewer, believe.”

    You could do the same thing with terrorists and hate groups: They believe in family and community! They’re proud of their heritage! Just like you and me! And the Unabomber believed in protecting the environment! Hooray!

    Maybe there could be a spin-off series showing how cults from the past, like Jonestown and Heaven’s Gate, were also totally relatable. How about an episode on the positive aspects of the Aum Shinrikyo subway nerve-gas attack?

  • Is it normalization or just a documentary? I haven’t seen it yet so I won’t pass judgement. Religion is one if the most interesting phenomena in human history and I enjoy learning all aspects of it, especially the “fringe”, a very subjective fringe.

    As an aside, an interesting story about the author took place in a Fox interview concerning his scholarly works about Jesus. The interviewer seemed perplexed that a Muslim chose Jesus and Christianity for his research. The look in his face as he tried to explain this was priceless.

  • I watched part of the Aghori episode last night. It didn’t seem like normalization to me. He literally ran away from this guru who started drinking his own urine. The more moderate Aghoris did not seem cult-like or extremist at all.